This is going to be fun.
I love horror movies. I love them! More than any kind of movie. It’s not March anymore, and it’s not yet October, but I thought it would be fun to match my favorite horror films against each other, March Madness bracket-style. I love too many horror movies to limit myself to just the traditional 64, which means this bracket will be SUPER SIZED with 128 MOVIES in 8 CATEGORIES.
I’ll be doing one match-up at a time until I'm done, and will explain my rationale for choosing the winner of each. If I had graphic skills I’d make a nice bracket graphic, but here is the slate for Round One! I'll delve more into my thinking behind my division of these films into each of these categories as I write about them.
Monster Mash: The Monstrous
Some of the oldest and finest works in the genre allow us to explore our fear of the other, the unknown, the almost-but-not-quite human. Here you get your witches, your zombies, your Draculas. If it’s a monster with supernatural origins, it belongs here. The sixteen films competing will be:
- Dracula Vs. The Wolfman
- Winner: Dracula
- Night of the Living Dead Vs. Phantasm
- Winner: Night of the Living Dead
- Cat People Vs. King Kong
- Winner: Cat People
- I Walked With a Zombie Vs. It Follows
- The Babadook Vs. The Mummy
- Candyman Vs. Nosferatu
- Let The Right One In Vs. The Howling
- Creature From the Black Lagoon Vs. An American Werewolf in London
It's Alive: Mad Science
Not every monster has supernatural origins, however: some are made in labs. If the weird shit going on has a pseudo-scientific justification (no matter how ridiculous), it belongs here. Here you find your rogue scientists, your genetic splicing, and your evil aliens. The sixteen films competing will be:
- Frankenstein Vs. Invaders From Mars
- Winner: Frankenstein
- Bride of Frankenstein Vs. Rabid
- Winner: Bride of Frankenstein
- Dead Ringers Vs. Altered States
- Winner: Dead Ringers
- Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde Vs. The Fly
- The Invisible Man Vs. The Last Man on Earth
- The Thing Vs. The Brood
- Alien Vs. Scanners
- 28 Days Later Vs. Eyes Without a Face
Three Final Girls Walk Into A Bar: Meta Horror and Horror Comedy
Comedy and horror are sister genres, and some of the earliest films blend the two. Here you’ll find not only horror parodies but films that use horror tropes to comedic effect. This is horror poking fun at itself. The sixteen films competing will be:
- Re-Animator Vs. Bubba Ho-Tep
- Winner: Re-Animator
- Shaun of the Dead Vs. Little Otik
- Winner: Little Otik
- Scream Vs. Death Proof
- Winner: Death Proof
- Young Frankenstein Vs. What We Do In The Shadows
- Cabin In The Woods Vs. Army of Darkness
- Little Shop of Horrors Vs. The World’s End
- The Rocky Horror Picture Show Vs. Beetlejuice
- The Old Dark House Vs. Ghostbusters
All Day Permanent Red: The Slasher
There’s horror that’s clever, there’s horror that’s cerebral, there’s horror that’s more quietly haunting than terrifying. And there’s horror that’s nothing but blood, blood, and more blood. Some of the films I picked for this category are more proto-slasher than true slasher, but they are all full of murder. The sixteen films competing will be:
- Blood and Black Lace Vs. The Bird With the Crystal Plumage
- Winner: Blood and Black Lace
- The Texas Chain Saw Massacre Vs. Alice, Sweet Alice
- Winner: The Texas Chain Saw Massacre
- Last House on the Left Vs. Five Dolls for an August Moon
- Psycho Vs. My Bloody Valentine
- Halloween Vs. I Spit On Your Grave
- Frenzy Vs. Friday the 13th
- Peeping Tom Vs. A Nightmare on Elm Street
- The Hills Have Eyes Vs. A Bay of Blood
Haves and Have-Nots: Home Invasion Horror
They say that your home is the place where when you go there, they have to let you in. It’s also the place where sometimes people in masks will break in and try to murder you for no reason. Nothing can highlight class tensions quite like a good home invasion story. The sixteen films will be:
- The Collector Vs. Death Weekend
- Winner: Death Weekend
- You’re Next Vs. The Visit
- Winner: The Visit
- Don’t Breath Vs. Panic Room
- The Purge Vs. Black Christmas
- The Strangers Vs. When A Stranger Calls
- Wait Until Dark Vs. Alone In The Dark
- Funny Games Vs. Assault on Precinct 13
- Straw Dogs Vs. Night of the Hunter
Whatever Walks There, Walks Alone: The Haunted House
Not all dangers invade a home; some come attached to it. Whether it’s a house, a castle, a school, or a hotel: if people live there and ghosts do too, it belongs here. The sixteen films competing will be:
- The Haunting Vs. House on Haunted Hill
- Winner: The Haunting
- The Shining Vs. Suspiria
- Winner: The Shining
- The Uninvited Vs. The Amityville Horror
- Crimson Peak Vs. The Legend of Hell House
- The Awakening Vs. The Changeling
- Poltergeist Vs. The Orphanage
- The Innocents Vs. The Woman in Black
- The Others Vs. 13 Ghosts
God Won’t Help You Now: Religious Horror
This was a trend in horror that exploded in the late sixties and early seventies: when young people were rejecting social convention on a mass scale and everyone was afraid of all institutions breaking down. But even before that, there was nothing scarier than the devil. The sixteen films competing will be:
- The Witch Vs. Seven
- Winner: The Witch
- The Omen Vs. Prince of Darkness
- Winner: Prince of Darkness
- Constantine Vs. The Exorcist
- Blood On Satan’s Claw Vs. The Devils
- To The Devil, A Daughter Vs. Faust
- The Black Cat (1934) Vs. The Wicker Man
- Witchfinder General Vs. The Devil Rides Out
- Rosemary’s Baby Vs. The Night of the Demon
The Monster In The Mirror: Socially Conscious Horror
Look, nearly all horror has subtext of one kind or another. It’s a genre that runs on subtext. And how can we better examine the state of society than by examining what scares us? Many of the films in other categories have rich political themes, but this category is for the films in which the sub-textual is made textual. These films have messages. The sixteen competing are:
- The Stepford Wives Vs. The Devil’s Backbone
- Winner: The Devil's Backbone
- Get Out Vs. Teeth
- Winner: Get Out
- They Live Vs. The Stuff
- Videodrome Vs. Jennifer’s Body
- Dawn of the Dead Vs. Dead of Night
- Invasion of the Body Snatchers Vs. Pan’s Labyrinth
- Two Thousand Maniacs! Vs. The People Under The Stairs
- American Psycho Vs. District 9